1. Toyota Yaris
One of the cutest cars for teenage girls is the Toyota Yaris. Besides being an extremely fun car to drive, the Yaris features a quirky design and is extremely affordable when buying the base model, and it does extremely well when it comes to gas mileage with a 30 MPG (city) and 36 MPG (highway) overall rating. When buying the car new, consumers can choose between a three or five-door hatchback, and one may also choose between a four-speed automatic or a five-speed manual transmission. The stock engine in the car is a 1.5 liter V-4 that is rated at 106 horsepower, but it does have a top speed of 108 MPH. Parents will be happy that the zero to 60 MPH time is only 10.2 seconds, so the teen will not be tempted to try to drive too aggressively.